Artemis Base Camp and Exploitation of Outer Space: Problems and The Needs of Legal Framework

Main Article Content

Irawati Handayani
Ms. Annisa
Mr. Garry

Abstract

NASA introduced the Artemis Program in 2017, consisting of several missions, such as establishing a permanent outpost called Artemis Base Camp and exercising commercial and non-commercial exploitation on the Moon. For the program to be carried out properly, the United States established a series of bilateral agreements with other countries, namely the Artemis Accords. One of the functions of the Accords is as the supporting legal instrument for the implementation of the Artemis Program. However, its implementation raised several legal problems related to the legality of establishing Artemis Base Camp and violations of the basic principles of space law related to activities. This paper will specifically discuss the legal issues arising from using the Artemis Accords as one of the supporting legal bases for the two Artemis Program activities, according to space law. This article argues that Artemis Base Camp falls within the definition of a station explained in the Outer Space Treaty and the Moon Agreement. Then, the construction does not violate the principle of non-appropriation in Article II of the Outer Space Treaty because it does not fulfill the three main components of appropriation activities. Although establishing the Artemis Base Camp and exploiting lunar resources for non-commercial purposes is permitted, a basic legal framework still needs to be established to regulate permanent outposts and the exploitation of lunar resource activities. A specific legal framework is needed to avoid multiple interpretations leading to legal uncertainty.

Article Details

How to Cite
Handayani, I., Juliana, A., & Gumelar, G. (2023). Artemis Base Camp and Exploitation of Outer Space: Problems and The Needs of Legal Framework. Padjadjaran Journal of International Law, 7(1). https://doi.org/10.23920/pjil.v7i1.1335
Section
Articles

References

Books
A, McNair, The Law of Treaties, OUP, London, 1961.
Cassese, Antonio, International Law, 2nd edn, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2005.
Chaikin, Andrew, A Man on the Moon: The Voyages of the Apollo Astronauts, Penguin, New York, 2007.
Diederiks-Verschoor, Isabella Henrietta Philepina dan Vladimir Kopal, An Introduction to Space Law 3rd Edition, Kluwer Law International, London, 2008.
Dorr, Oliver, Kirsten Schmalenbach, Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties: A Commentary, 2nd Edition, Springer, Verlag, 2018.
Dorr, Oliver, Kristen Schmalenbach, Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, A Commentary, Second Edition, Springer, Germany.
Dunk, Frans von der dan Fabio Tronchetti, Handbook of Space Law, Edward Elgar, Massachusetts, 2015.
Freeland, Steven & Ram Jakhu, “Article II” in Stephan Hobe, Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd, & Kai-Uwe Schrogl, Cologne Commentary On Space Law, Luxemburg: Wolters Kluwer Deutschland GmbH, 2009.
Grotius, Hugh, De Jure Belli ac Pacis, Libri Tres, Trans. Francis W. Kelsey, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1925.
Hobe, Stephan, Introduction to International Law, 10th edn, Perancis, Tübingen 2014.
Hobe, Stephan, The Legal Framework for the Economic Use of Space, Duncker & Humblot, Berlin, 1992.
Hobe, Stephen, Bernhard Schmidt-Tedd, Kai-Uwe Schrogl (Editors), Cologne Commentary on Space Law, Outer Space Treaty, Volynskaya, Katsura-Trumpel, Ladeyshchikov (Translators), Wolters Kluwer Deutschland GmbH, Berlin, 2009.
Jakhu, Ram S., Joseph N. Pelton, Yaw O.M Nyampong, Space Mining and Its Regulation, Springer Praxis Books, Switzerland, 2017.
Jennings QC, Sir Robert and Arthur Watts, Oppenheim's International Law (9th edition) Vol. 1, Longmans, UK, 1992.
Kusumaatmadja, Mochtar, Pembinaan Hukum Dalam Rangka Pembangunan Nasional, Penerbit Binacipta, Bandung, 1986.
Lo, Chang-fa, Treaty Interpretation Under the Vienna Conventions on the Law of Treaties: A New Round of Codifications, Springer Nature Singapore, Singapore, 2017
Lyall, Larsen, Space Law: A Treatise, Ashgate Publishing Limited, Farnham, 2009.
Noordung, Hermann, E. Stuhlinger, J.D Hunley, The Problem of Space Travel; (NASA History Series no. SP-4026), Military Bookshop, US, 2011.
Oduntan, Gbenga, Sovereignty and Jurisdiction in Airspace and Outer Space: Legal Criteria for Spatial Delimitation, Routledge, Oxford, 2011.
Reijnen, Bess CM, The United Nations Space Treaties Analysed, Edition Frontieres, Perancis, 1992.
Shaw, Malcolm N., International Law: Sixth Edition, Cambridge University Press, Edinburgh, 2008.
Tronchetti, Fabio, The Exploitation of Natural Resources of the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies: A Proposal for a Legal Regime, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden, 2009.
Viliger, Mark E, Commentary on the 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, Leiden, 2009.
Wolfrum, Rüdiger, Max Planck Encyclopedia of Public International Law, Oxford Public International Law, Oxford.
Young, Andrew J, Law Policy in the Space Stations’ Era, Martinus Nijhoff, Boston, 1989.

Article Journal
A. Zammit Borda, “A Formal Approach to Article 38 (1)(d) of the ICJ Statute from the Perspective of the International Criminal Courts and Tribunals,” European Journal of International Law, Vol. 24, No. 2, 2013.
Abigail D. Pershing, “Interpreting the Outer Space Treaty’s Non-Appropriation Principle: Customary International Law from 1967 to Today”, The Yale Journal of International Law, Vol. 44, No. 1.
Aldo Armando Cocca, “Mankind as a New Legal Subject: A New Juridical Dimension Recognized by the United Nations”, Proceedings of the 13th Colloquium on the Law of Outer Space (AIAA), 1970.
Aldo Armando Cocca, “The Advances in International Law Through the Law of Outer Space”, Journal of Space Law, Vol. 9, No. 13, 1981.
Aldo Armando Cocca, “The Principle of the “Common Heritage of All Mankind” as Applied to Natural Resources from Outer Space and Celestial Bodies”, Proceedings of the 16th Colloquium on the Law of Outer Space (AIAA), 1973.
Antonella Bini, “The Moon Agreement: Its Effectiveness in the 21st Century”, European Space Policy Institute Perspectives, No. 14, 2008.
F.G. Von der Dunk, “The Moon Agreement and the Prospect of Commercial Exploitation of Lunar Resources”, Annals of Air and Space Law, Vol. 32, 2007.
Fabio Tronchetti, “Non-Appropriation Principle Under Attack: Using Article II of the Outer Space Treaty in Its Defence”, International Institute of Space Law, Vol. 50, 2007.
Heidi Keefe, “Making the Final Frontier Feasible: A Critical Look at the Current Body of Outer Space Law”, Santa Clara High Technology Law Journal, Vol. 11. No.2, 1995.
Joanne Gabrynowicz, “The Province and Heritage of Mankind Reconsidered”, Second Conference on Lunar Bases and Space Activities of the 21st Century, Houston, 5-7 April, 1988.
K. Tatsuzawa, "The Regulation of Commercial Space Activities by The Non-Governmental Entities in Space Law", IISL, 1989.
Laszlo Keszthelyi, Justin Hagerty, Amanda Bowers, Karl Ellefsen, Ian Ridley, Trude King, David Trilling, Nicholas Moskovitz, and Will Grundy,” Feasibility Study for the Quantitative Assesment of Mineral Recoursces in Asteroids”, USGS, 2017.
Marshall Smith, Douglas Craig, Nicole Herrman, Erin Mahoney, Jonathan Krezel, Nate McIntyre, Kandyce Goodliff, “The Artemis Program: An Overview of NASA’s Activities to Return Humans to the Moon”, IEEE Aerospace Conference, 2020.
Martin Elvis, Alanna Krolikwski, dan Tony Milligan, “Concentrated Lunar Resources: Imminent Implication for Governance and Justice”, Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society A, 2020.
Michael Dodge, “Sovereignty and Delimitation of Airspace: A Philosophical and Historical Survey Supported by the Resources of the Andrew G Haley Archive, Journal of Space Law, Vol. 35, No. 5, 2009, 2009.
Mukhidin, “Hukum Progresif sebagai Solusi Hukum yang Mensejahterakan Rakyat”, Jurnal Pembaharuan Hukum, Vol. 1, No. 3, 2014.
N. Labeaga Martinez, M. Sanjurjo Rivo, J. Diaz Alvarez, J. Martinez Frias, “Additive Manufacturing for a Moon Village”, Procedia Manufacturing, Vol. 13, 2017.
Philip De Man, “Luxembourg Law on Space Resources Rests on Contentious Relationship with International Framework”, Working Paper No. 189, July, 2017.
Ram Jakhu, “Legal Issues Relating to the Global Public Interest in Outer Space”, Journal of Space Law, Vol. 32 No. 31, 2006.
Rana H.S., “The Common Heritage of Mankind and the Final Frontier: A revaluation of Values Constituting the International Legal Regime for Outer Space Activities”, Rutgers Law Journal, Vol. 28, 1994.
S. Coffey, “Establishing a Legal Framework for Property Rights to Natural Resources in Outer Space”, Case Western Reserve Journal International Law, Vol. 41, No. 119, 2009.
Scott J. Shackelford, “The Tragedy of the Common Heritage of Mankind,” Stanford Environmental Law Journal, Vol. 28, 2009.
Senjuti Mallick & Rajeswari Pillai Rajagopalan, “If Space is ‘the Province of Mankind’, Who Owns its Resources? An Examination of the Potential of Space Mining and its Legal Implications”, ORF Occasional Paper, Vol. 182, 2019.
Stephan Hobe, “Adequacy of the Current Legal and Regulatory Framework Relating to the Extraction and Appropriation of Natural Resources”, Institute of Air and Space Law, McGill University, Policy and Law Relating to Outer Space Resources: Examples of the Moon, Mars, and other Celestial Bodies, Workshop Proceedings, 2006.
Stephan Hobe, “Outer Space as the Province of Mankind – An Assessment of 40 Years of Development”, Proceedings of the 50th Colloquium on the Law of Outer Space (AIAA), 2007.
Stephen Gorove, “Arms Control Provisions in the Outer Space Treaty: A Scrutinizing Reappraisal”, Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law, Vol. 3, 1973.
Stephen Gorove, “Interpreting Article II of the Outer Space Treaty”, Fordham Law Review, Vol. 37, 1969.
Stephen Gorove, “The Concept of “Common Heritage of Mankind”: A Political, Moral or Legal Innovation?”, San Diego Law Review, Vol. 9, 1972.
Vladimir Kopal, “The Role of United Nations Declarations of Principles in the Progressive Development of Space Law”, Journal of Space Law, Vol. 16, No. 1, 1988.
Wasser Alan, Douglas Jobes, “Space Settlements, Property Rights, and International Law: Could a Lunar Settlement Claim the Lunar Real Estate It Needs to Survive”, Journal of Air Law and Commerce, Vol. 73, No. 1, 2007
Wei Yang, Yangtin Lin, “New Lunar Samples Returned by Chang’E-5: Opportunities for New Discoveries and International Collaboration”, The Innovation, 2021.

International Agreement and Conventions
Agreement Governing the Activities of States on the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies 1979 [Moon Agreement].
The Artemis Accords, Principles for Cooperation in the Civil Exploration and Use of the Moon, Mars, Comets, and Asteroid for Peaceful Purposes [Artemis Accords].
The Outer Space Treaty, formally the Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies 1967.
Vienna Convention on the Law of the Treaties 1969.

Judicial Decision
Golder v. United Kingdom, ECHR, Series A, No. 18, Judgment, European Court of Human Rights, 1975.
Territorial Dispute Case (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya v. Chad), Judgment, I.C.J. Reports, 1994.

United Nations Documents
United Nation General Assembly Resolution, 1472 (XIV), 12 Desember 1959.
___________________________________, 1348 (XIII), 13 Desember 1958.
___________________________________, 1721 (XVI), 20 Desember 1961.
___________________________________, 1802 (XVII), 14 Desember 1962.
Final Act on the UN Conference on the Law of Treaties.
UNCOPUOS, Catatan Verbatim dari Pertemuan Keempat Puluh Empat, UN GAOR, sesi ke-8, Pertemuan ke-44, UN Doc A/AC.105/PV.44, 25 Oktober 1966.
United Nation Document A/AC, 105/85, Annex II.
United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs, https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/copuos/index.html.

Others
Committee of the Whole of the Vienna Conference on the Law of Treaties, 1968.
Edwin Z. Crues, “Returning to the Moon: Plans for Distributed Simulation in the Artemis Program”, The 25th International Symposium on Distributed Simulation and Real Time Application, Spanyol, 29 September 2021.
NASA, “International Partners Advance Cooperation with First Signings of Artemis Accords”, https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-international-partners-advance-cooperation-with-first-signings-of-artemis-accords.
NASA, Artemis Plan, //www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/files/artemis_plan-20200921.pdf,
Official Records of the Vienna Conference on the Law of Treaties, 1968
Senate Committee on Aeronautical and Space Sciences, “Treaty on Principles Governing the Activities of States in the Exploration and Use of Outer Space, including the Moon and Other Celestial Bodies: Analysis and Background Data”, 90th Congress, 1st Session, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, 1967.
The Ministry of Economy of Luxembourg, “Luxembourg’s New Space Law Guarantees Private Companies the Right to Resources Harvested in Outer Space in Accordance with International Law”, 2016, http://www.spaceresources.public.lu/content/dam/spaceresources/press-release/2016/2016_11_11PressReleaseNewSpacelaw.pdf.
U.S Department of State, “Artemis Accords, Enabling International Partnerships for Lunar Exploration”, https://www.mcgill.ca/iasl/files/iasl/06us_artemis_accords_enabling_international_partnerships_for_lunar_exploration.pdf.
U.S Department of State, “Artemis Accords, Enabling International Partnerships for Lunar Exploration”, https://www.mcgill.ca/iasl/files/iasl/06usartemisaccordsenablinginternationalpartnershipsforlunarexploration.pdf.
U.S. Commercial Space Launch Competitiveness Act 2015.
Yearbook of the International Law Commission, Vol. I, 1964.
Britannica, “Hayabusa”, https://www.britannica.com/technology/spacecraft.
EuraAsian Times, “China, Japan, India Continue to Spearhead Asia’s Meteoric Rise in Space Exploration”, https://eurasiantimes.com/china-japan-india-continue-to-spearhead-asias-meteoric-rise-in-space-exploration/.
Global Times, “Lunar Research Station to Be Inked by China and Russia This Year, Operational by 2035: CNSA”, https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202201/1250142.shtml.
Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, “Hayabusa 2”, https://www.isas.jaxa.jp/en/missions/spacecraft/current/hayabusa2.html.
Institute of Space and Astronautical Science, “Hayabusa”, rhttps://www.isas.jaxa.jp/en/missions/spacecraft/past/hayabusa.html.
Jan Woerner, “A Vision for Global Cooperation and Space 4.0”, European Space Agency, https://www.esa.int/About_Us/Ministerial_Council_2016/Moon_Village.
Merriam Webster, https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/.
Mining Technology, “The History of Space Mining: Five Key Events for Mineral Exploration Space”, https://www.mining-technology.com/features/history-of-space-mining/.
NASA, “Clementine Project Information”, http://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetry/clementine.html.
NASA, “International Partners Advance Cooperation with First Signings of Artemis Accords”, https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-international-partners-advance-cooperation-with-first-signings-of-artemis-accords.
NASA, “LCROSS Overview, LCROSS”, http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/LCROSS/overview/index.html.
NASA, “Lunar Prospector Mission, LCROSS”, http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/LCROSS/ searchforwater/lunar_prospector.html.
NASA, “Northrop Grumman Finalize Moon Outpost Living Quarters Contract”, https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-northrop-grumman-finalize-moon-outpost-living-quarters-contract.
Oxford Online English Dictionary.
Pat Dasch, Michael Martin-Smith, & Anne Pierce, “National Space Society”, Presentasi di the 50th International Astronautical Congress: Conference on Space Property Rights: Next Steps, Oct. 4-8, 1999.
Shane D. Ross, “Near-Earth Asteroid Mining”, Space Industry Report, 2001, http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.614.9343&rep=rep1&type=pdf.
Space.com, “Russia, China Reveal Moon Base Roadmap but No Plans For Astronaut Trips Yet”, https://www.space.com/china-russia-international-lunar-research-station.
The Diplomat, “China, Russia Agree to Cooperate on Permanent Moon Base”, https://thediplomat.com/2021/03/china-russia-agree-to-cooperate-on-permanent-moon-base/.
The European Space Agency, “Helium-3 Mining on the Lunar Surface”, http://www.esa.int/ Our_Activities/Preparing_for_the_Future/Space_for_Earth/Energy/Helium-3_mining_on_the_lunar_ surface.
The New York Times, “China Brings Moon Rocks to Earth, and a New Era of Competition to Space”, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/16/science/china-moon-mission-rocks.html.
U.S. Congressman Billy Posey, “Bipartisan Legislation Promotes Commercial Space Ventures”, https://posey.house.gov/news/documentprint.aspx?DocumentID=387391.
Wayne N. White Jr., “Real Property in Outer Space 1”, Presentasi di the 40th Colloquium on the Law of Space of the American In